- Quality Inn Arcola6.6Arcola
- Relax Inn & SuitesMattoon5.8
- Willow e-hotel6.8Mattoon
- Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Mattoon by IHG6.1Mattoon
- Best Western Heartland Inn8.1Mattoon
- Super 8 by Wyndham Mattoon7.6Mattoon
- Days Inn by Wyndham Charleston7.1Charleston
- Quality Inn & Suites Mattoon South8.4Mattoon
- Hilton Garden Inn Mattoon, IL9.1Mattoon
- Country Home Near EIU and Lake Charleston!Charleston9.7
- Willow e-hotelMattoon
- Comfort Suites Mattoon East8.2Mattoon
- Unique Suites Hotel6.6Charleston
- Suite Dreams Motel Mattoon I 576.7Mattoon
